Learn
How the Brutal Cybercrime of Pig Butchering Goes In for the Kill
If the name of the increasingly common form of cybercrime known as "pig butchering" makes you recoil, wait until you hear about the crime itself.
Pig butchering drained Mississippi retiree Barry May of $500,000 — his entire life savings.1 For the family of 82-year-old Dennis Jones of Virginia, the fallout was even worse: Jones took his own life after losing everything to pig butchering.2
Elements of this horrendous cybercrime may sound familiar. Pig butchering is part cryptocurrency scam, part romance or confidant scam and part investment scam. What sets it apart is both its specific methodology and its goal of draining victims of every last dollar they have. And it's so effective that a 2024 academic study estimated it has robbed victims of up to $75 billion worldwide.3
Here's what everyone should know about pig butchering, from what it is to how to protect yourselves and your loved ones from this brutal cybercrime.
What Is Pig Butchering? (And Why the Graphic Name?)
As disgusting as the name is, the metaphor is fitting: Pig butchering is a cybercrime in which a scammer slowly nurtures a relationship with a victim — not unlike how a farmer nurtures a pig while fattening it up. When the scammer manipulates every bit of money out of the victim they can (think: the pig is maximally fattened up), they suddenly "slaughter" the relationship, disappearing with the victim's money.
How Does Pig Butchering Work?
Pig butchering is a cybercrime that, as noted above, shares elements with other known scams but has its own distinct method. It begins as terribly as it often ends: Pig butchering is often perpetrated by organized crime rings outside the U.S. that typically force human trafficking victims to carry out the scam.4
These victim-scammers (referred to going forward as simply "scammers," though it is important to remember they are victims themselves) then follow a reliable pattern, according to FinCEN, the U.S. Department of the Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network:4
- The scammer contacts a potential victim on dating sites, social media channels, online professional networks, or messaging apps. The first message is often under the guise of messaging an old friend at the wrong number.
- If the victim responds, telling them they have the wrong number, the scammer strikes up a charming, casual conversation anyway.
- The scammer takes their time establishing a deep relationship with the pig butchering victim. It can be romantic or simply a friendship. As the relationship slowly grows, the victim may connect with the scammer's fake social media identity showing a lavish lifestyle. The scammer will claim to have a job in finance, like as an investor or money manager.
- After building trust, the scammer will introduce a fake investment opportunity using cryptocurrency. They'll direct the victim to legitimate-seeming websites or apps that supposedly manage the investments.
- Once the victim is interested, the scammer will offer to help them purchase the cryptocurrency using remote access to the victim's device or requesting screenshots. They are also sometimes directed to make write transfers or purchase prepaid cards to buy the crypto.
- Once the victim has purchased the cryptocurrency, the scammer asks them to invest the funds in the supposed investment websites or apps.
- The scammer shows the victim excellent supposed returns on their investment through the fake website or app, sometimes even allowing them to withdraw some funds as proof. Then, they pressure the victim to invest more. The returns appear to be so great that maximizing their investment seems like a smart move.
- Once the victim has invested all they are willing to — which, for many, includes liquidating assets or taking out a home equity loan — the scammer will make a final push for funds, asking for withdrawal fees or tax payments to release the victim's supposed investment returns.
- Finally, when the scammer is satisfied that the victim cannot or will not hand over any more money, they'll abruptly end communications with the disappear — with the victim's entire investment.
Why Pig Butchering Is So Effective
It's easy to assume you'd never get drawn into a pig butchering scam. But even a Kansas bank CEO was taken in so fully by pig butchering that he turned to crime himself, embezzling $47 million from his bank customers and stealing tens of thousands from his church, investment club and his daughter's college fund — all to invest in the scam.5
Pig butchering's goal is to drain victims of every last dollar they have. A 2024 academic study estimated it has robbed victims of up to $75 billion.
The crime is so effective because it strategically plays on victims' vulnerabilities. The crime syndicates behind the scam have developed scripts and playbooks designed to work on a large scale.6 The victims are targeted, often for being lonely, elderly, or otherwise vulnerable, and the scam intentionally takes its time earning their trust.
According to Stacey Wood, Ph.D. in Psychology Today, pig butchering is a type of cybercrime that "insidiously take[s] advantage of various psychological attributes and cognitive strategies, including weaknesses, blind spots, biases and heuristics [mental shortcuts for problem-solving], to infiltrate defenses and successfully scam consumers."7 And remember, the "scammers" are often victims as well, desperate to succeed at all costs for their own survival.
How To Protect Yourself From Pig Butchering
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, or FINRA, offers the following tips for protecting yourself from pig butchering:8
- Do not respond to unexpected messages from strangers, even to tell them they have the wrong number. If it's truly a mix-up, they'll figure it out themselves.
- Invite new online friends to video chat. If they repeatedly decline, it's a sign they're not who they say they are.
- Never share personal or financial information with someone you've never met in person. An online friend asking for money or information you'd otherwise protect is a big red flag.
- Never accept an invitation from an online friend to invest in a specific financial product or take advantage of an investment tip. Ask how they stand to benefit from your investment. Confusing opportunities, unfamiliar trading platforms, and cryptocurrency requirements are all signs of fraud.
- Avoid any investment opportunities accompanied by exaggerated claims or emotions. If a big return is guaranteed or you have to act now to get in on an investment, it's not likely to be above board.
Protecting loved ones can be less straightforward, as you may not see these red flags yourself. In the case of Dennis Jones' family, the only sign during the scam itself was that he withdrew from his family.2 But the general rules of protecting loved ones from fraud apply here: educate them about the signs of a pig butchering scam, explain that they should never send money to anyone they've met online, and keep in touch with them about their finances, including checking their credit report regularly. (For more tips, see this article on protecting elders from financial scams.)
Because pig butchering takes advantage of victims emotionally, people who have or suspect they have been fooled are often too embarrassed to admit they've been scammed. But at the first sign that you or a loved one might be a victim of pig butchering, report it to the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center9 and read about other important steps to take in our article What to Do if You Are a Victim of Fraud.
Important disclosure information
Asset allocation and diversifications do not ensure against loss. This content is general in nature and does not constitute legal, tax, accounting, financial or investment advice. You are encouraged to consult with competent legal, tax, accounting, financial or investment professionals based on your specific circumstances. We do not make any warranties as to accuracy or completeness of this information, do not endorse any third-party companies, products, or services described here, and take no liability for your use of this information.
- Ken Dilanian, "With ‘pig butchering’ scams on the rise, FBI moves to stop the bleeding," NBC News, published February 5, 2024. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- Teele Rebane and Ivan Watson, "Killed by a scam: A father took his life after losing his savings to international criminal gangs. He’s not the only one," CNN, published June 20, 2024. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- John M. Griffin and Kevin Mei, "How Do Crypto Flows Finance Slavery? The Economics of Pig Butchering," SSRN, published March 28, 2024. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- U.S. Department of the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), "FinCEN Alert on Prevalent Virtual Currency Investment Scam Commonly Known as 'Pig Butchering,'" published September 8, 2023. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- Martha Mendoza, "A courtroom of relief: FBI recovers funds for victims of scammed bank," AP News, published November 4, 2024. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- Lily Hay Newman, "Hacker Lexicon: What Is a Pig Butchering Scam?" Wired, published January 2, 2023. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- Stacey Wood, Ph.D., "Why "Pig Butchering" and Other Scams Are on the Rise," Psychology Today, published June 22, 2023. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- FINRA, "‘Pig Butchering' Scams: What They Are and How to Avoid Them," published December 13, 2022. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
- Internet Crime Complaint Center, Complaint Form, FBI. Accessed November 7, 2024. Back
Do you have questions or ideas?
Share your thoughts about this article or suggest a topic for a new one